Why ERP implementations fail to deliver value

ERP implementations

The landscape of enterprise resource planning (ERP) is littered with failed implementations. According to Analyst firm Gartner, 55% to 75% of all ERP projects fail to deliver their intended value. This statistic show that CIOs need to examine their approaches. By examining the failure reasons it becomes clear that a shift towards more agile and user-centric methodologies is needed.

The Root Causes of ERP Failure:

  • Lack of Clear Business Objectives: Many ERP projects lack a clear definition of success. Without well-defined goals and measures, it becomes impossible to know if an implementation meets the expectation and it becomes a subjective.
  • Insufficient User Involvement: When users are not involved in the design, testing, and training phases, the resulting configuration are less likely to fit, leading to low adoption rates, data quality issues, and ultimately, project failure.
  • Underestimating Complexity: ERP implementations are complex undertakings that require careful planning, disciplined execution, and ongoing maintenance. Underestimating the scope, complexity, and potential challenges can lead to significant delays, budget overruns, and ultimately, project failure.
  • Data Migration Issues: Migrating data from legacy systems to the new ERP can be a major hurdle. Data quality issues, incomplete data migration, and unforeseen data inconsistencies can severely impact the accuracy and reliability of the new system.
  • Lack of Business Transformation: The intended modernization of the business meets with practicalities during the implementations. Project team members may not feel empowered enough to disrupt processes and structures and thereby revert back to the old.
  • No Plan for Administration: Every implementation is just a starting point. Modern ERP systems allow for configuration changes after go-live. When there are no teams designated for ongoing the maintenance, the implementation feedback will remain unattended.

The Consequences of Failure:

Failed ERP implementations have significant consequences for businesses:

  • Loss of Trust: When ERP projects fail to deliver, users quickly lose trust in IT and the organization’s ability to implement and support critical systems. This can have a detrimental impact on employee morale and productivity.
  • Missed Opportunities: Businesses not able to move fast enough due to inefficient and unreliable systems miss out on valuable market opportunities and struggle to compete effectively.
  • Financial Losses: ERP projects can be costly, and failed implementations result in significant financial losses due to wasted resources, lost productivity, and the need for costly remediation efforts.
  • Reputational Damage: Failed ERP implementations can damage an organization’s reputation, both internally and externally, impacting customer relationships and investor confidence.

Shifting Towards a Continuous Mindset:

To overcome these challenges, CIOs must embrace a more continuous and iterative approach to ERP maintenance. This involves:

  • Continuous Improvement: Treating ERP as an ongoing journey, rather than a one-time project.
  • Agile Methodologies: Adopting agile principles, such as iterative development, frequent feedback loops, and continuous testing, to improve flexibility and responsiveness.
  • User-Centric Design: Prioritizing user needs and actively involving users throughout the entire implementation lifecycle.
  • Data Quality Focus: Implementing robust data quality processes to ensure accurate and reliable data migration and ongoing maintenance.
  • Continuous Training and Support: Providing ongoing training and support to users to ensure they can effectively utilize the system and address any issues that arise.

By embracing a continuous mindset and prioritizing user needs, CIOs can significantly increase the likelihood of successful ERP implementations and ensure that these critical systems deliver the value they promise.

Teamup9 Consulting

At Teamup9 Consulting, we empower admin teams to play a pivotal role in driving business success. We provide the expertise and support their team needs to optimize the system and deliver measurable results.

We partner with Workday Administrators and Functional Users to maximize the value of their Workday investment by providing comprehensive support, enhancements, and optimization services. Our approach equips teams with the tools, knowledge, and confidence to complete critical projects and move business forward. By fostering collaboration and promoting self-sufficiency through mentoring and knowledge transfer, we create lasting value for teams at all levels.

Share on LinkedIn